By Nada Hassanein, Stateline.org
VALDOSTA, Ga. — Abby Jones’ first cease of the day delivering remedy was the house of 90-year-old Sarah Campbell Kier.
“Come in!” yelled Kier. Jones didn’t need to knock. Kier had the display door open and was ready for the Barnes Drug Retailer driver, who additionally had delivered Kier’s thyroid remedy the day earlier than.
“I appreciate you bringing my medicine, darling,” stated Kier, a retired faculty cafeteria employee. She sat on the sofa by her walker, writing a $3 examine for her prescription B12 complement. Kier is having surgical procedure later this month, and stated she is glad she will depend on the pharmacy for pre- and post-op remedy administration.
Kier’s household has been shopping for from Barnes Drug Retailer since she was a toddler dwelling within the countryside. “We had to come to town to get our food and medicine,” she stated.
Barnes Drug Retailer is an unbiased pharmacy within the south Georgia city of Valdosta that’s been serving the neighborhood for a century. The family-run enterprise used to have six pharmacies. It now has only one.
Impartial drugstores are closing at an alarming charge — about one a day in 2023 — squeezed by the massive firms that reimburse pharmacies for expensive medicines.
However with every closure, a neighborhood loses greater than one other place the place they will purchase drugs. Consultants say unbiased drugstores usually tend to know their patrons, provide well being and medicine counseling, and, crucially, serve communities in want.
A 2023 research funded by the Nationwide Institutes of Well being discovered that the estimated 15.1 million Individuals who depend on independently owned pharmacies usually tend to have decrease incomes, stay in rural areas and to be a minimum of 65 years previous. Their well being is extra difficult, they usually’re extra prone to want one-on-one counseling to juggle a number of medicines.
In consequence, these communities — already weak to lack of care — are hardest hit when unbiased pharmacies shutter. Decrease drug reimbursements in contrast with these provided to chain pharmacies, resembling CVS and Walgreens, are an enormous issue.
“They’re going to close. If they’re relying on insurance, it’s not sustainable,” stated Dima Mazen Qato, a College of Southern California medical pharmacy and spatial sciences professor who research pharmacy entry.
In latest research, Qato and her staff discovered unbiased pharmacies have been extra prone to shut in contrast with chain pharmacies — they usually have been extra prone to shutter in Black and Latino communities already going through disproportionate boundaries to care.
“You would think there would be more accountability for ensuring that the pharmacies providing care for these patients are protected from closure,” Qato stated.
In Valdosta, Georgia, a metropolis of 55,000 not removed from the Florida state line that’s surrounded by rural counties, many residents lack transportation and endure persistent well being circumstances that require remedy. Fifty-six % of Valdosta’s residents are Black, and most of the surrounding communities, resembling Echols and Hamilton counties in North Florida, are residence to migrant employees.
Delivering prescriptions to a roughly 30-mile radius, Barnes Drug Retailer serves as a cornerstone for the world, the place many cities lack a hospital, pharmacy, pediatrician or main care supplier.
Proprietor Charles Barnes III, 78, stated his grandfather opened the pharmacy in 1909, passing it down by way of generations. “We know the families that come to our store,” he stated. His son, Charles Barnes IV, is the CEO. The family-run enterprise has diversified its companies, with different areas that provide residence infusion and respiratory remedy companies, serving to the corporate, Barnes Healthcare Companies, keep afloat.
Final 12 months, Georgia Republican Gov. Brian Kemp vetoed a invoice that may have required the state’s medical insurance program for lecturers and state employees to reimburse unbiased pharmacies on the identical charge as chain pharmacies, saying the initiative can be too expensive and was unaccounted for within the price range. The invoice had obtained bipartisan, virtually unanimous assist within the Basic Meeting.
“We have no negotiation power,” stated Ben Ross, president and board chair of the Georgia Pharmacy Affiliation, which represents pharmacists throughout the state.
“We definitely have a reimbursement issue, where pharmacies are struggling not because of volume, not because they don’t have the patients, but because of the reimbursements that we’re being paid by the PBMs,” he added.
Pharmacy profit managers, or PBMs, are firms serving as pharmaceutical middlemen. They handle insurance coverage firms’ prescription drug advantages, processing between 80% and 90% of prescriptions distributed nationwide. They determine how a lot to reimburse a pharmacy for every prescription. Large chains resembling CVS and Walgreens routinely get higher reimbursements than unbiased drugstores.
Ross, a second-generation pharmacist, runs Forest Heights Pharmacy within the jap Georgia city of Statesboro. He’s additionally a associate in seven different pharmacies — most of them in rural elements of the state.
“If these pharmacies in these communities close,” Ross stated, “what are these patients in these communities supposed to do?”
‘Taking a risk’ to assist sufferers
At Springfield Pharmacy in Delaware County, Pennsylvania, proprietor Chichi Ilonzo Momah estimates that as much as 30% of medicines she fills are reimbursed for lower than what they value.
Up to now 12 months, she stated, three unbiased pharmacies in her space have closed. Lately, though she knew a pregnant affected person’s insurance coverage wouldn’t cowl an RSV vaccine, she gave her the shot anyway.
“I’m taking a risk,” Momah stated, figuring out that if a reimbursement wouldn’t undergo and the affected person couldn’t pay, she can be within the pink.
Momah opened Springfield Pharmacy 13 years in the past, and the shop primarily serves the uninsured, in addition to a big immigrant and refugee inhabitants. She’s shaped trusted relationships with residents through the years. At instances, she’s referred to as to remind clients to take their medicines if she is aware of they’ve been susceptible to forgetting, they usually’ll usually search her recommendation on medicines and vaccines once they’re skeptical or confused.
“That’s what happens when there’s a trusted voice in the community,” Momah stated. “‘If Chichi says it’s OK, it’s OK.’ … They’re asking me, just like the way my aunt will ask me, or the way my mother-in-law asks me, the way my dad would ask me.”
When Stateline referred to as her, the pharmacist was packing prescriptions for a affected person on 14 medicines.
“If I put it in 14 vials, he can get confused. He’s 82 years old, so I put it in adherence packaging that says, ‘Monday morning,’ ‘Monday evening,’“ she said. “That right there — you cannot put a price tag. The PBMs can’t pay for that. It’s customized care.”
In latest months, Momah has needed to begin turning some sufferers away.
“That broke my heart. Some of them, I couldn’t even tell them. I had to have my staff do it, because I’ve known them for 13 years. I’ve hand-delivered medications to their homes,” she stated. “I don’t understand why in America, the PBMs don’t answer to somebody. Because pharmacies are going to continue to close.”
Pharmacy deserts
In a December letter to the incoming Trump administration’s proposed authorities effectivity committee, the Nationwide Group Pharmacists Affiliation, which represents unbiased pharmacies throughout the nation, urged President-elect Donald Trump to rein within the three PBM conglomerates: CVS Well being’s Caremark, Cigna-owned Specific Scripts and UnitedHealth’s Optum Rx. The affiliation stated regulating the PBMs would save taxpayers $5 billion.
“We are up against these giant, vertically integrated health care conglomerates, and so that’s tough,” Ronna Hauser, the affiliation’s senior vp of coverage and pharmacy affairs, advised Stateline.
Greg Lopes, a spokesperson for the Pharmaceutical Care Administration Affiliation, which represents PBMs, argued that they alone aren’t in charge for pharmacy closures, saying they’re discovering methods to assist rural pharmacies.
“There are many factors for pharmacy closures, including population. Pharmacy benefit managers are supporting community pharmacies in rural areas through programs that increase reimbursements,” he wrote in a press release to Stateline.
However a scathing Federal Commerce Fee report launched Tuesday builds on a earlier report that discovered PBMs had obtained 68% of the income from meting out specialty medication in 2023. The brand new report discovered that PBMs seem like steering sufferers to their very own affiliated pharmacies for probably the most worthwhile medication, and away from unaffiliated, unbiased pharmacies.
The closures, and the responses, are taking place throughout.
In Alabama, 21 neighborhood pharmacies and a dozen chain pharmacies closed throughout Alabama final 12 months alone, based on the Alabama Pharmacy Affiliation.
“If you take care of all patients like we always have, you’ll go out of business,” stated Bobby Giles, a pharmacist and the affiliation’s authorities affairs director, including that Medicaid’s fixed-rate reimbursements are usually greater than what PBMs pay pharmacies in his state.
“We, as pharmacists, are literally asking for you to pay us the same rate of reimbursement that the poorest of the poor and the sickest of the sick in our state’s insurance pays,” Giles stated.
Some states have taken steps in recent times to assist unbiased pharmacies. Final fall, Louisiana Republican Gov. Jeff Landry signed an emergency contract that goals to enhance reimbursement charges for unbiased pharmacies.
In 2019, Illinois began a vital entry pharmacy program, permitting small neighborhood pharmacies serving Medicaid sufferers to obtain supplemental cash from the state. Two years later, Tennessee handed a legislation that prohibits PBMs from reimbursing pharmacies under acquisition prices.
Each rural and concrete pharmacies are closing their doorways, although it’s taking place barely sooner in rural communities, analysis reveals. Almost 16 million Individuals stay in pharmacy deserts throughout the nation, and on common, communities which are uninsured and which are extra racially various disproportionately lack entry to pharmacies.
Delesha Carpenter, a professor and director of the Rural Analysis Alliance of Group Pharmacies on the College of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, stated her surveys of neighborhood pharmacies have discovered the shops taking a whole bunch of {dollars} of losses per prescription because of inequitable reimbursements.
“I would love to see more legislative initiatives … bolstering rural pharmacy,” stated Carpenter. She famous that pharmacists can’t invoice medical insurance firms for the counseling and training they do every day, which Carpenter stated would assist convey in additional income.
Private service
Pharmacist Tyler Younger and his spouse purchased Hines Prescription Store in Barnesville, Georgia, an hour south of Atlanta, in 2021. Barnes advised Stateline he takes a $75 loss on Ozempic prescriptions for one month’s provide per affected person.
Younger, 31, grew up across the pharmacy. His mother was an authorized pharmacy technician and labored at Hines Prescription Store. His freshman 12 months of school, he bought a part-time job on the store.
“Seeing the impact that the local community pharmacy had on their town really drove me to be involved in this profession,” stated Younger, who additionally owns Roberta Medication, one other pharmacy he and his spouse bought in 2019.
“We knew that it was possible, even with some of the challenges that we faced, it was still possible to serve our communities how we wanted to,” he stated.
On a latest morning again at Barnes Drug Retailer, Robert Morrison, 69, waited within the retailer foyer for his prescription to be crammed. As a young person, Morrison labored for Barnes delivering drugs.
He had a liver transplant 5 years in the past, and with 10 to 12 completely different prescriptions, Morrison stated he generally will get his medicines combined up and asks the workers for assist.
“It’s a good thing for the neighborhood,” stated Morrison, a yard employee. “I’ve been dealing with them a long time.”
Employees pharmacist Loryn Brown stated she usually counsels clients on their medicines and signs.
“I’ve sent numerous patients to the ER because of high blood pressures that they didn’t realize were actually an emergent situation,” Brown stated.
Again at Kier’s residence in Valdosta, Kier mirrored on the pharmacy closures throughout her state. “That’s so sad,” she stated, excited about residents unable to get their medicines.
“Uh-uh — I don’t feel good,” Kier continued, “because I don’t want my Barnes to close.”
©2025 States Newsroom. Go to at stateline.org. Distributed by Tribune Content material Company, LLC.
